For years, a group of dumpsters have been stinking up Gould Street. So why hasn’t TMU moved them? The answer may have something to do with the school’s cramped urban campus and ever-shifting identity
By Yuna Cho
IT’S MID-SEPTEMBER and architectural science lecturer Scott Sorli knows exactly where he’s taking his students for a quick lesson: the Gould Street dumpster.
Marked by an enclosure at the corner of Gould and Church Streets, just outside Kerr Hall, the streaks of brown on the pavement are the unmistakable sign of the infamous waste site—that is, if the pungent smell in the air didn’t tip you off first.
With the second-year students of his architecture studio, Sorli goes on a tour of the campus from the Architecture Building to the World Food Market on Yonge Street, where the class this year is conducting a field study. On the tour, he hopes to teach them the history of the buildings and urban elements around them.
That’s what makes the dumpster a necessary pit stop, Sorli says. His group of 13 stand around the enclosed site, slightly perturbed by the smell (“garbage juice,” one professor suggests), but they know why he’s brought them here. Sorli asks his students to be conscious of the architectural decisions made in the world around them. He asks them to question: where would you put the garbage? Surprisingly, it’s not always an easy answer.
Over the last several years, as Toronto Metropolitan University (TMU) has rapidly grown, the stench of the Gould Street dumpster has, unfortunately, part of the campus character. Sat in a public-facing part of campus, it’s become a question that many is asking—why is the refuse of the school out in the open for everyone to smell?
Sorli doesn’t necessarily agree that the dumpster should be smack in the middle of the university. But the answer as to why it’s there may say something about the school’s urban identity.
THE RYERSON INSTITUTE of Technology—today, TMU—was first established in 1948. Just 250 people made up its first batch of students. Fast forward to nearly 80 years later, and the since-accredited university sees upwards of 45,000 students each year and has expanded to take over more of the downtown core.
To this day, the heart of the university and one of its main buildings given its sheer size, is Kerr Hall. It’s among the older buildings of the university, having been built in the 1960s. It may also have a role to play in the stink.
The main reason the garbage area is located where it is today, according to Sorli, may be related to the anti-urban philosophies that influenced city planning and architecture during the mid-twentieth century. That philosophy, as some experts explain, was a reaction to increasing urbanization by those who didn’t believe a city was the ideal place for people to live.
Before it was the Ryerson Institute of Technology or TMU, the school was a teachers’ college known as the Toronto Normal School in the mid-1800s. When Howard Kerr came into leadership, it was renamed and transformed into a post-secondary institution—with that came big construction changes. The old buildings of the Toronto Normal School had to be demolished, and instead, were replaced with what we know today as Kerr Hall.
“The parti for the new academic building… was a three-storey block with a raised basement built around a courtyard,” a study on the history of Kerr Hall establishes. The main entrance to the complex was through a gate to the north on Gerrard Street, while two smaller archways on Gould Street welcomed people from the south. The building had pedestrian access on all four sides, but for a while, it was Gerrard Street that was more popularly used.
What the architects of the over half-a-century-old Kerr Hall may not have imagined was that the area around their waste site on the Gould Street side would soon become a heavily pedestrianized zone, someday leaving hundreds of 20-somethings with no choice but to hold their breaths as they walk by.
In a statement to The Eyeopener, the university said the area “is a central waste depository on campus for multiple buildings. Given the Toronto TMU Campus is located in an urban setting with space limitations, this has been the most suitable location.”
But Sorli says now that we’ve moved away from those mid-century philosophies, TMU’s approach to garbage should develop, too.
“I think that the university is maintaining a legacy that is anti-urban in form because of that dumpster’s location,” he says. “But now I think that the conception of the city is a much more positive one than it was when this building was built. And so we need to accommodate our new understanding of our experiences of the city as a potentially positive one and not to denigrate it through leaving garbage around.”
As for the smell, Sorli thinks it may be a combination of food and waste, forced to mingle for several days on end, under the beating sun in the summer, that gives off an unseemly stench. The run-off on the streets, he says, is the same kind of liquid that collects at the bottom of a garbage can.
“It was really bad, it’s always stinky and I don’t know why it’s in the middle of the campus.”
Although the school has expanded in recent years—something that Chris De Sousa, an urban planning professor at TMU did not necessarily expect to see—it still doesn’t cater itself to freely rearranging things.
“I don’t think it was ever intended to grow as well as it has,” De Sousa says. “I think it was meant to be Kerr Hall and some smaller buildings, and it’s grown kind of with the downtown.” Before Gould Street became a pedestrian intersection, De Sousa says because of the nature of Kerr Hall and its entrances, Gerrard Street would have been the entry point as it was a vehicle-heavy zone, while Gould Street would have been the less busy street.
But as TMU began to expand north, east, south and west, the flow of traffic changed, too. Now, Gould and Church are among the busiest intersections with dozens of students waiting to cross at all hours of the day.
Other comparable universities in the city like the University of Toronto (U of T) and York University, own large swaths of land. U of T St. George sits on more than 180 acres; York’s Keele Campus is one of the largest in Canada at over 500 acres. TMU trails far behind, jamming 43 buildings on just 27 acres. TMU has largely grown through the acquisition of nearby buildings as they vacate. Most recently, the university has taken on the old Toronto Public Health building at Victoria and Dundas, as well as a collection of buildings on Dundas and Bond, including the Imperial Pub, which will soon be home to a 1,370-bed residence. On Church Street, the school is adding five stories to O’Keefe House, turning it into the new Centre for Student Wellbeing. But changing how the old buildings operate, like Kerr Hall, which is heritage-listed, costs more, and so it comes down in the list of priorities.
The growing number of students on campus have already made every corner of it home. De Sousa, an urbanite through and through, still marvels every time he walks down campus these days—the rock at Lake Devo now blasts music and even well into the evening, he finds students gathered along the paved university grounds, sitting outside of Balzac’s and enjoying the urban life.
“The reality is, as that street has become pedestrianized, it’s become more popular, and you get more people eating lunch, students liking to linger and enjoy their time there,” De Sousa says.
It’s a sweet development but the problem of the smell remains. In fact, it’s perhaps a question of the university’s reputation.
ANORA CONSTANTINE AND Kesavy Baskaran were among the hundreds of eager students that packed TMU during this year’s Orientation Week. The biomedical science and computer science majors respectively were excitedly exploring the campus they’d call theirs.
Something they haven’t forgotten from that week, however, was the stench as they crossed Gould Street. “It was my first impression,” Constantine says. “It was really bad, it’s always stinky and I don’t know why it’s in the middle of the campus.”
Constantine says she recognizes the campus is in a dense downtown, but says the dumpster’s presence in the middle of it leads her to question the university’s attention towards sanitation nonetheless.
For its part, the university says it is making efforts to address the leakages and smells. “We do recognize that as is common in an urban setting, there are sometimes odours and leakage from this space and we make ongoing efforts to address this. These efforts include power-washing the surrounding area and cleaning the compactor. This past summer, we also installed additional absorbents and deodorizers,” a statement reads.
But some students don’t feel these efforts are making an impact. “I didn’t want to come to Oakham Cafe, [Daphne Cockwell Complex] or the engineering building,” Baskaran says, thanks to the smell. The pair have classes in the engineering building, and to get there, they use Dundas Street East and avoid the intersection all together.
The waste depository is a big enough problem that it’s become a recurring topic on the r/TorontoMetU subreddit.
“I simply stop breathing,” one user said was their solution. “Personally, I have set paths that I walk depending on where I need to go. These paths also, on average, have the least annoying outdoor smells. But normally, when you get ‘surprised’ by the smell, a quick breath hold and fast walk will help you get out of it,” another poster advised.
Sorli says there is something to be said architecturally about the response to the reeking dumpster—a stench even he calls revolting “in a certain sense.”
“Smell is an urban condition,” Sorli says. But it’s one that’s long been overlooked in architecture. As it stands currently, some experts suggest that much of urban planning revolves around visual aspects. But the experts also say that smell plays a big role in our lasting perception of a place. For decades, parts of TMU have, simply put, stunk. Compared to universities like U of T and York that are contained within a set of “walls,” even figuratively so, TMU prides itself on being a part of the city in a way the others are not. Because of that, it gets slapped with the same label as Toronto does: unclean—because of the way humans perceive bad smells, as signalling a dangerous or unsatisfactory place.
“Given the Toronto TMU Campus is located in an urban setting with space limitations, this has been the most suitable location”
TMU Facilities Management and Development
De Sousa says in the grand scheme of things, the problem TMU faces is not that big a deal. Rather, for urbanites, the various smells of a city, good or bad, are part of the experience. Like chirping birds add character to a forest, smell gives character to the city. All of his favourite educational experiences have been on campuses that were deeply embedded in an urban zone, with all the pains that comes with being at the centre of it all.
“If you’re an urbanite, and you like urban things, and you like the big lights, big city action, the noise, the variety of people, then this is the kind of place that you want to be. If you want to be in a campus with benches and lollipop trees, probably go somewhere else,” De Sousa says with a laugh.
So why the Gould Street dumpster smells is a moot point—it is a dumpster. Instead, the question is whether we can fix the problem of it being a university landmark.
IN TMU’S CAMPUS master plan, the redevelopment of Kerr Hall is central. The building has been dubbed an “opportunity site,” meaning it’s a candidate for internal renovations to “refresh and improve the existing space,” or to be demolished entirely.
The plan hopes to make the Kerr Quad the campus “jewel” by turning it into a community park that provides a green space for the university. The existing building would be replaced by two taller buildings on each side, known as the “New West Park Building” and the “New East Park Building” in the concept plan. However, it’s not clear what the redevelopment would mean for the dumpster or waste management on the whole.
De Sousa and Sorli both say that expectations that the dumpster would be moved in the redevelopments have to be tempered.
“That’s what makes planning in a city kind of more interesting, is that you’ve gotta navigate these challenges and try to come up with the best solution of the bunch, and you’re never gonna make everyone happy, but you try to find the better compromise,” De Sousa says.
For Sorli, the question of why things haven’t changed sooner may also come down to funding. “The university itself is cutting back on, let’s just say maintenance and care of the institution, and instead it’s spending more money on security and disciplining of the institution,” he argues. Sorli says he feels he sees more security guards on campus than care-takers. “That’s a financial choice of the university that I think is perhaps misplaced priorities.”
According to this year’s budget report, the annual deferred maintenance increased by half a million dollars.
De Sousa agrees that maintenance may not receive as much funding presently—it’s one of the expenses that many institutions in Ontario considered expendable during the tuition freeze, as funds may have gotten tighter, he says. An opinion piece in The Globe and Mail last year suggests the “financial chokehold” Ontario universities have been placed in means they are cutting programs, jobs and deferring maintenance. But De Sousa doesn’t think more money is going into one pocket than another.
He says students and their students’ union should find ways to enhance the campus as volunteers and, like he sometimes wipes down tables as a professor, take responsibility for the campus they spend time on and keep it clean.
Still, if it’s a matter of the school’s reputation, Sorli thinks it is worth every penny. That’s why he makes his students stand in front of the dumpster and bear witness—so when it comes time for them to be architects themselves, they may do so with more attention to the inhabitants in mind.
“I want them to experience the negative aesthetic of the smell of the garbage because that’s what everyone experiences,” Sorli says. “Someone comes to Toronto Metropolitan University and expects a quality educational experience—and this is the welcome that they get at one of the most important thresholds to the university. I think it’s just a mistake.”






Leave a Reply